Part 4: The Basement Interrogation

The drive from the safehouse back to my suburban neighborhood took exactly eleven minutes behind the wheel of an old, primer-gray Ford pickup I kept registered to a dead man's social security number. The streets were completely deserted now, the midnight mass crowds long gone, the snow piling up against the curbs like white barricades. I parked two blocks away from my house, killing the headlights before the vehicle rolled to a stop beneath a broken streetlamp.
I approached my property from the tree line along the western fence, moving through the deep snow without breaking a single branch. My house, usually the brightest one on the block with its rows of white fairy lights and the handmade wooden snowman Noah had helped me build, was completely dark. The police had cleared out hours ago after taking their initial samples, leaving the front door sealed with yellow crime-scene tape that fluttered weakly in the wind.
But the basement bulkhead door at the back of the house was unlatched. A thin sliver of light was visible through the rusted iron hinges.
I slipped through the opening, dropping down onto the concrete floor of the utility room with the weightless silence of a shadow. The air downstairs was cold, smelling of old paint cans and the damp earth of the crawlspace. From the far corner, near the main electrical panel, came the rhythmic, high-pitched hum of the degausser and the sound of metal scraping against metal.
"Come on, you piece of garbage," Brian muttered, his breath coming in short, ragged gasps as he struggled to pry open the heavy steel lockbox that contained my redundant server array. "Open up."
I stepped out from behind the water heater, the muzzle of my silenced USP .45 leveled directly at the center of his forehead.
"The key is under the fake brick on the third row, Brian," I said, my voice barely above a whisper, yet it cut through the hum of the machine like a wire cutter.
Brian froze. His entire body turned rigid, the crowbar remaining wedged into the steel frame of the box. He slowly turned his head, his face turning an ash-gray color beneath the glare of his headlamp as he saw me standing there. The cocky, intellectual college friend who used to brag about his summer house in the Hamptons looked like he had just stared into the mouth of a furnace.
"David..." he choked out, his hands beginning to shake so violently the crowbar rattled against the metal. "David, listen to me... you shouldn't be here. The police are looking for you everywhere. They think you did it. They think you went crazy."
"I know what they think," I said, taking two slow, deliberate steps forward until the cold steel of the silencer was resting exactly between his eyebrows. "And I know what you did. I watched the driveway footage from 2:15 p.m. I watched Daniel hand you the pouch. And I watched you pass the aconitine to Judith at 4:30 p.m."
A drop of sweat rolled down Brian’s temple, freezing near his cheekbone. "You... you don't understand... I didn't have a choice. Daniel... Daniel owes five million to some very bad people in Atlantic City. They were going to kill him, David! They were going to kill Rachel and the kid! He said Emma’s estate was the only way out. He promised me ten percent if I brought the chemical back from the lab in New York. He said it would look like a natural heart attack! He said nobody would ever suspect poison!"
"But you didn't just target Emma, did you?" I asked, my finger tightening on the trigger until the slack was entirely gone. "You poisoned the gravy boat. You knew my children were going to eat that food. You watched a six-year-old girl spoon that sauce onto her plate, and you sat there and smiled."
"It was Judith!" Brian yelled, dropping to his knees, his hands thrown up in a desperate plea for mercy. "Judith insisted! She said Emma wouldn't eat enough of it if it was just on her plate! She said we had to clear the whole line so there wouldn't be any survivors to contest the inheritance! I didn't want the kids to get hurt, I swear to God, David! I didn't know she was going to use that much!"
"Where is Daniel right now?" I asked, my voice remaining perfectly level, a clinical instrument of interrogation.
"He's... he's at his office downtown," Brian stammered, the tears finally breaking through his eyes, cutting lines through the dust on his face. "The old printing warehouse on Archer Avenue. He's setting up the financial transfers... they have a lawyer waiting to file the emergency guardianship papers for the estate the second the hospital pronounces Emma dead. Please, David... don't kill me. I’ll testify. I’ll tell the police everything. I’ll give you Daniel on a silver platter."
I looked at him for three long seconds. In the field, a compromised asset who offers up his handlers is a liability—they will say whatever it takes to survive the next five minutes, then change their story the moment they are behind a bulletproof partition.
"I don't need your testimony, Brian," I said quietly. "I already have the video."
Before he could scream, I brought the heavy steel butt of the pistol down across the side of his temple. The blow was calculated with the exact force required to fracture the temporal bone without causing fatal intracranial bleeding. He dropped like a sack of stones onto the concrete, his headlamp spinning across the floor until it pointed toward the dark corner of the cellar.
I used two high-tensile plastic zip-ties from my vest to secure his wrists to the heavy iron water main pipe, then stuffed his mouth with a thick ball of duct tape. He wouldn't be going anywhere for at least twenty-four hours—long enough for me to clear the final two targets on my board.
I picked up his dropped cell phone from the floor. The screen was unlocked. The last text message was from Daniel, sent fifteen minutes ago: Is the server clear? The hospital just called. Lily’s vitals are dropping. We need to move the paperwork before morning.
May you like
My grip on the phone tightened until the glass screen cracked under my thumb.
"Hold on, Lily," I whispered into the dark basement. "Daddy's coming."